Playoffs
| Year | Playoff | Round | W/L | Score | Opponent | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1975 | Lakota Invitational Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 37-20 | Monroe Hornets | Lakota HS |
| Semifinal | L | Lakota Thunderbirds | Lakota HS | |||
| 1976 | Class A Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 44-43 | Ripley Bluejays | Anderson HS |
| Final | W | 41-15 | Fayetteville-Perry Rockets | Anderson HS | ||
| Class A District Tournament | Semifinal | W | 44-32 | Clinton-Massie Falcons | Anderson HS | |
| Final | W | 34-31 OT | East Clinton | Anderson HS | ||
| Class A Regional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 30-43 | Russia Raiders | University of Dayton | |
| 1977 | Class A Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 52-39 | Williamsburg Wildcats | Turpin HS |
| Final | W | 47-38 | Clinton-Massie Falcons | Turpin HS | ||
| Class A District Tournament | Semifinal | W | 54-34 | Summit Country Day Silver Knights | Turpin HS | |
| Final | W | 51-38 | Macon Eastern | Turpin HS | ||
| Class A Regional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 38-62 | Arcanum Trojans | University of Dayton | |
| 1977-78 | Class A Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 78-14 | Cincinnati Seven Hills | Cincinnati Garden |
| Final | W | 61-31 | Batavia Bulldogs | Cincinnati Garden | ||
| Class A District Tournament | Semifinal | W | 46-37 | Georgetown G-Men | Cincinnati Garden | |
| Final | W | 40-33 | St.Bernard Titans | Cincinnati Garden | ||
| Class A Regional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 53-58 | Mechanicsburg Indians | University of Dayton | |
| 1978-79 | Class A Sectional Tournament | Final | W | 55-24 | New Miami Vikings | Madeira HS |
| Class A District Tournament | Semifinal | W | 56-26 | Felicity-Franklin Cardinals | Madeira HS | |
| Final | W | 52-50 | Cincinnati Country Day Indians | Madeira HS | ||
| Class A Regional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 33-36 | Fort Loramie Redskins | University of Dayton | |
| 1979-80 | Class A Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 66-21 | St.Bernard Titans | Madeira HS |
| Final | W | 48-36 | Fayetteville-Perry Rockets | Madeira HS | ||
| Class A District Tournament | Semifinal | W | 42-40 | Macon Eastern | Madeira HS | |
| Final | W | 55-49 | Cincinnati Country Day Indians | Madeira HS | ||
| Class A Regional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 60-61 | Sidney Lehman Catholic Cavaliers | Fairmont West HS | |
| 1980-81 | Class A Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 63-33 | Yellow Springs Bulldogs | University of Dayton |
| Final | W | 59-30 | Bradford Railroaders | University of Dayton | ||
| Class A District Tournament | Semifinal | W | 68-40 | Twin Valley North Panthers | University of Dayton | |
| Final | W | 69-34 | Ansonia Tigers | University of Dayton | ||
| Class A Regional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 42-45 | Georgetown G-Men | University of Dayton | |
| 1981-82 | Class A Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 45-23 | Bradford Railroaders | University of Dayton |
| Final | W | 64-42 | Xenia Woodrow Wilson Cadets | University of Dayton | ||
| Class A District Tournament | Semifinal | W | 34-33 | Twin Valley North Panthers | University of Dayton | |
| Final | L | 57-59 | Waynesville Spartans | University of Dayton | ||
| 1982-83 | Class A Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 34-32 | Tipp City Bethel Bees | University of Dayton |
| Final | W | 55-32 | Cedarville Indians | University of Dayton | ||
| Class A District Tournament | Semifinal | W | 50-24 | Twin Valley North Panthers | University of Dayton | |
| Final | W | 56-49 | Lees Creek East Clinton | University of Dayton | ||
| Class A Regional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 52-44 | Fort Loramie Redskins | Xenia HS | |
| Final | W | 60-51 | Howard East Knox Bulldogs | Xenia HS | ||
| Class A State Tournament | Semifinal | L | 38-54 | Mansfield St.Peter's Spartans | The Ohio State University | |
| 1983-84 | Class A Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 34-42 | Tri-County North Panthers | Wilbur Wright HS |
| 1984-85 | Class A Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 39-49 | Tri-County North Panthers | Wilbur Wright HS |
| 1985-86 | Class A Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 37-38 | Waynesville Spartans | Wilbur Wright HS |
| 1986-87 | Class A Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 58-47 | Waynesville Spartans | Wilbur Wright HS |
| Final | L | 43-48 | Yellow Springs Bulldogs | Wilbur Wright HS | ||
| 1987-88 | Division 4 Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 45-30 | Williamsburg Wildcats | Madeira HS |
| Final | W | 69-51 | Ripley Bluejays | Madeira HS | ||
| Division 4 District Tournament | Final | L | 50-70 | South Charleston Southeastern Trojans | Vandalia-Butler HS | |
| 1988-89 | Division 4 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 79-35 | Ripley Bluejays | Madeira HS |
| Semifinal | W | 68-8 | Cincinnati Christian Cougars | Madeira HS | ||
| Final | W | 62-22 | Cincinnati Summit Country Day Silver Knights | Madeira HS | ||
| Division 4 District Tournament | Final | L | 37-43 | Fort Loramie Redskins | Vandalia-Butler HS | |
| 1989-90 | Division 4 Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 59-20 | Dayton Jefferson Broncos | Wilbur Wright HS |
| Final | W | 55-31 | Yellow Springs Bulldogs | Wilbur Wright HS | ||
| Division 4 District Tournament | Final | W | 37-22 | DeGraff Riverside Pirates | Vandalia-Butler HS | |
| Division 4 Regional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 34-22 | South Charleston Southeastern Trojans | Vandalia-Butler HS | |
| Final | W | 37-22 | Cincinnati Madeira Amazons | Vandalia-Butler HS | ||
| Division 4 State Tournament | Semifinal | W | 30-23 | New Washington Buckeye Central Bucks | The Ohio State University | |
| Final | L | 41-54 | Fort Recovery Indians | The Ohio State University | ||
| 1990-91 | Division 4 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 37-26 | Mississinawa Valley Blackhawks | Wilbur-Wright HS |
| Semifinal | W | 47-26 | Pitsburg Franklin-Monroe Jets | Wilbur-Wright HS | ||
| Final | W | 50-41 | New Madison Tri-Village Patriots | Wilbur-Wright HS | ||
| Division 4 District Tournament | Final | W | 53-37 | Houston Wildcats | Vandalia-Butler HS | |
| Division 4 Regional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 44-38 | South Charleston Southeastern Trojans | Vandalia-Butler HS | |
| Final | L | 40-45 | Fort Loramie Redskins | Vandalia-Butler HS | ||
| 1991-92 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 43-37 | New Lebanon Dixie Greyhounds | Monroe HS |
| Final | L | 44-47 | Bellbrook Eagles | Monroe HS | ||
| 1992-93 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 49-32 | Preble Shawnee Arrows | Monroe HS |
| Semifinal | W | 44-27 | Madison Mohawks | Monroe HS | ||
| Final | W | 41-40 | Valley View Spartans | Monroe HS | ||
| Division 3 District Tournament | Final | L | 53-55 OT | Springfield Kenton Ridge Cougars | Vandalia Butler HS | |
| 1993-94 | Division 4 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 56-29 | Twin Valley South Panthers | Wilbur Wright HS |
| Semifinal | W | 49-36 | Cedarville Indians | Wilbur Wright HS | ||
| Final | L | 53-61 | South Charleston Southeastern Trojans | Wilbur Wright HS | ||
| 1994-95 | Division 4 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | L | 40-41 | Mississinawa Valley Blackhawks | Wilbur Wright HS |
| 1995-96 | Division 4 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 77-38 | Newton Indians | Wilbur Wright HS |
| Semifinal | W | 62-48 | Dayton Jefferson Township Broncos | Wilbur Wright HS | ||
| Final | W | 50-46 | New Madison Tri-Village Patriots | Wilbur Wright HS | ||
| Division 4 District Tournament | Final | W | 54-41 | Russia Raiders | Vandalia Butler HS | |
| Division 4 Regional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 32-70 | South Charleston Southeastern Trojans | Vandalia Butler HS | |
| 1996-97 | Division 4 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | L | 46-51 | Fayetteville-Perry Rockets | Madeira HS |
| 1997-98 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 59-53 | Carlisle Indians | Mason HS |
| Semifinal | W | 53-39 | Cincinnati Mariemont Warriors | Mason HS | ||
| Final | L | 32-58 | North Bend Taylor Yellow Jackets | Mason HS | ||
| 1998-99 | Division 4 Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 46-32 | Cincinnati Summit Country Day Silver Knights | Madeira HS |
| Final | L | 37-41 | Cincinnati Country Day Indians | Madeira HS | ||
| 1999-00 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 51-27 | Cincinnati Deer Park Wildcats | Mason HS |
| Semifinal | W | 47-43 | Batavia Bulldogs | Mason HS | ||
| Final | L | 27-65 | Cincinnati Wyoming Cowboys | Mason HS | ||
| 2000-01 | Division 4 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | L | 34-46 | Cincinnati Seven Hills Stingers | Waynesville HS |
| 2001-02 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 31-43 | Waynesville Spartans | Wilmington HS |
| 2002-03 | Division 4 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 43-27 | Newton Indians | TV South HS |
| Semifinal | W | 51-23 | Mississinawa Valley Blackhawks | TV South HS | ||
| Final | W | 49-38 | Pitsburg Franklin-Monroe Jets | TV South HS | ||
| Division 4 District Tournament | Final | W | 29-27 | South Charleston Southeastern Trojans | Vandalia Butler HS | |
| Division 4 Regional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 36-50 | Maria Stein Marion Local Flyers | Vandalia Butler HS | |
| 2003-04 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 49-27 | Springfield Northeastern Jets | Wilmington HS |
| Semifinal | W | 60-27 | Jamestown Greeneview Rams | Wilmington HS | ||
| Final | W | 44-31 | Blanchester Wildcats | Wilmington HS | ||
| Division 3 District Tournament | Final | L | 35-49 | Cincinnati Hills Christian Academy Eagles | Harrison HS | |
| 2004-05 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 36-21 | Clarksville Clinton-Massie Falcons | Wilmington HS |
| Semifinal | W | 42-27 | Monroe Hornets | Wilmington HS | ||
| Final | L | 29-51 | Georgetown G-Men | Wilmington HS | ||
| 2005-06 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 50-15 | Carlisle Indians | Wilmington HS |
| Semifinal | W | 44-19 | Springfield Northeastern Jets | Wilmington HS | ||
| Final | W | 46-31 | Waynesville Spartans | Wilmington HS | ||
| Division 3 District Tournament | Final | L | 39-50 | Versailles Tigers | Vandalia Butler HS | |
| 2006-07 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 59-22 | Twin Valley South Panthers | Wilmington HS |
| Semifinal | W | 55-20 | North College Hill Trojans | Wilmington HS | ||
| Final | W | 44-30 | Waynesville Spartans | Wilmington HS | ||
| Division 3 District Tournament | Final | L | 37-52 | Anna Rockets | Vandalia Butler HS | |
| 2007-08 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 31-13 | Jamestown Greeneview Rams | Wilmington HS |
| Semifinal | L | 44-53 | Madison Mohawks | Wilmington HS | ||
| 2008-09 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 41-28 | Blanchester Wildcats | Wilmington HS |
| Final | W | 46-39 | Waynesville Spartans | Wilmington HS | ||
| Division 3 District Tournament | Final | L | 29-46 | Miami East Vikings | Vandalia Butler HS | |
| 2009-10 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 38-35 OT | Springfield Northeastern Jets | Wilmington HS |
| Semifinal | L | 36-52 | Badin Rams | Wilmington HS | ||
| 2010-11 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 43-38 | Blanchester Wildcats | Wilmington HS |
| Semifinal | L | 31-33 | Springfield Northeastern Jets | Wilmington HS | ||
| 2011-12 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 35-27 | North College Hill Trojans | Monroe HS |
| Final | L | 36-68 | Badin Rams | Monroe HS | ||
| 2012-13 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 54-49 | Reading Blue Devils | Edgewood HS |
| Final | L | 30-44 | Madison Mohawks | Edgewood HS | ||
| 2013-14 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 34-39 | North College Hill Trojans | Willmington HS |
| 2014-15 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 32-35 | Jamestown Greeneview Rams | Wilmington HS |
| 2015-16 | Division 2 Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 27-70 | Alter Knights | Lebanon HS |
| 2016-17 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | L | 31-54 | Thurgood Marshall Cougars | Lebanon HS |
| 2017-18 | Division 2 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | L | 33-52 | Oakwood Lumberjacks | Lebanon HS |
| 2018-19 | Division 2 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 38-35 | Chaminade Julienne Eagles | Lebanon HS |
| Semifinal | W | 53-46 | Badin Rams | Lebanon HS | ||
| Final | L | 35-47 | Franklin Wildcats | Lebanon HS | ||
| 2019-20 | Division 2 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 58-26 | Stivers Tigers | Lebanon HS |
| Semifinal | L | 34-36 | Badin Rams | Lebanon HS | ||
| 2020-21 | Division 2 Sectional Tournament | Quarterfinal | W | 69-28 | Dunbar Wolverines | Middletown HS |
| Semifinal | W | 49-36 | Madison Mohawks | Middletown HS | ||
| Final | L | 36-39 | Badin Rams | Middletown HS | ||
| 2021-22 | Division 2 Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | W | 41-37 | Ross Rams | Middletown HS |
| Final | L | 34-59 | Alter Knights | Middletown HS | ||
| 2022-23 | Division 2 Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 29-59 | Summit Country Day Silver Knights | Loveland HS |
| 2023-24 | Division 3 Sectional Tournament | Semifinal | L | 34-47 | Mariemont Warriers | Wilmington HS |
| Total | 93-50 | |||||